Showing posts with label divorce lawyers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label divorce lawyers. Show all posts

Friday, August 4, 2017

The Anatomy of a Divorce Trial


The Great Unknown

Divorce is stressful for all parties involved.  Not only is your marriage falling apart but you are having to live as a single person and a single parent.  Divorce is the "Great Unknown".  Not only is divorce stressful in this context, but it is in the legal context as well.  Most people know the general idea behind the divorce process, but the exact details, the ins and outs and the general minutiae are a mystery to most people.  Today, I would like to jump to the end and talk about the Anatomy of a Divorce Trial.

The Typical Divorce

Most people think that you pay your attorney, file for divorce, fight with each other more and then go to court and the judge decides your fate.  While this is an exaggerated description, it is what most people think.  There is a sense of mystery surrounding working out all the details and getting the parties divorced.

In general, you can have a divorce that goes smoothly and amicably, one that is a knock down drag out fight or, more likely, one where there are details to be worked out, hoops to jump through and negotiating to be done.   It is that type of divorce that I would like to focus on here as it is the most common.

In this type of divorce, the parties generally agree on some things.  Often they will agree on how to split the debts and the property or they will agree on how to parent the kids.  However, even though they have a lot of agreement, there may be sticking points; things they just can't agree to even with the help of mediation.

So what happens then?  If this is the type of divorce you have found yourself in, it is likely that your attorneys will help you negotiate what you can and in the end you may be left with a few issues to present to the judge.  This is where your divorce trial will be.

The Divorce Trial or Trying the Issues

In these situations you aren't really having a full blown trial, you are trying the issues.  Your divorce attorneys will present your issues, along with your evidence to the judge.  Unlike other legal cases, the judge may indicate to the lawyers that he or she will not hear the issue and that the parties need to work it out themselves.  Obviously, if they cannot work them out the judge ultimately decides, but what the judge is saying is, "Come on you guys.  This is your stuff.  Figure it out".  If you get this message from your attorney, it means the judge thinks the parties together would make a better decision than the judge and the judge then is giving you the opportunity to make the best decision.

What type of issues present themselves in a Trying the Issues case?  Really any issue can be a sticking point or be presented to the judge.   You can have child custody issues where the parties can't agree on a visitation schedule.  You can have property issues where the parties cannot agree on a division of the community property.  Often you have matters of principle.  Grounds for the divorce, for example, can be a place of contention.  Sometime a party won't agree to agree unless the other party agrees that the divorce happened because of adultery or extreme cruelty instead of irreconcilable differences.

Trying the issues is by far the most common resolution to a divorce next to the parties actually negotiating an agreement with the aid of their divorce lawyers.

If you are need a Boise Divorce Attorney or have questions, please give us a call at (208) 472-2383 or visit us at our website or our sister site.  You will be glad you did.


Thursday, June 4, 2015

Facebook and Divorce - How Can Facebook Evidence Be Used in Court

Divorce and Facebook Evidence 

I have discussed before the admissibility of Facebook evidence in Court.  What I mean by this is using Facebook post by your ex or soon to be ex against them as evidence when you go before an Idaho divorce judge.  As a Boise Divorce Attorney, I have myself used evidence to show questionable character of the other party such as lying, exaggeration or pulling one over on the court.  As the use of Facebook becomes more ubiquitous, the nature of the evidence and its admissibility may be questioned more by the court. 

Facebook Posts and Divorce

It dawned on me the other day that much of what is put on Facebook is what we call in the law, puffery. Puffery is a form of exaggeration; maybe not quite lying but putting forth an image that differs from reality.  I read an article about how the more time people spend surfing social media, the more likely they are to become depressed.  This depression stems from seeing their friends' wonderful, exciting lives.  Their friends are displaying their lives as this fascinating display of vacations, events, awards and so on. 
What does this Facebook puffery have to do with divorce or evidence in the divorce court?  To state the obvious from the view of a Boise Divorce Attorney, overuse of Facebook is a symptom which can lead to issues which can fuel an already failing marriage such as increasing the chance of infidelity or an preoccupied emotionally absent spouse.  The other issue divorce lawyers face is in light of the way people puff their posts, can any or all Facebook posts be used against the side?  An illustrative example might be the divorcing wife who claims that she spends all her time with the child and the husband does nothing but drink, go out to bars and party.  If I, as a divorce attorney, show Facebook posts of the wife drinking and partying does that really show her true character?  What if I show Facebook posts of the husband doing housework and playing with the child?  Does this contradict that evidence? 

Is Facebook Evidence a Smoking Gun?

I believe that while Facebook can provide a source of evidence, it is evidence which will require corroborating evidence to make it stand.  In other words, a Facebook post may or may not be sufficient evidence to establish custody in one party or another, show questionable character, perjury or anything else for that matter. 

If you are facing a divorce and need to speak with a Boise Divorce Attorney, give us a call and see what we can do for you, 208-472-2383.

Friday, July 6, 2012

Boise Family Law Lawyers - (208) 472-2383 Separate and Community Property


Separate and Community Property
As a Boise Divorce Attorney I have spoken frequently in this blog and in others about community property.  To be brief, community property is that property which is acquired during a marriage with community funds.  This is in contrast to separate property.  The distinction between the two is important because upon divorce, community property is divided equally or equitably because it belongs to both parties.  At divorce, however, separate property remains the sole property of the original owner, unless….

As a Family Law Lawyer I deal with “unless…” a lot.  How and why would separate property become an unless?  In the world of family law there is something known as comingling.  Comingling exists in divorce law as well as business law.  It is the act of mixing property or money so that the original source is unclear.  It also often entails a lack of desire to keep property separate which can indicate a sharing nature.  Because there is a mixing, the property becomes transmuted.   Transmuted is a fancy legal word for changed.  As in all these blogs, when I discuss something technical, I am sure it is clear as mud.  Let me try to remove the mud and explain.

Comingling
Speaking in hypotheticals:  

Wife has cold hard cash from a previous marriage.  She marries new Husband.  Wife places her cash in her own bank account.  Wife never uses money from her account to pay for anything related to the community.  Husband and Wife get a divorce.  It is clear that Wife always kept her money separate.  She never mixed it with money from the community.  It remains her own separate property.

Now let’s take Wife and Husband again but change the circumstances a little bit.  Say Wife and Husband are married.  Say Wife’s parents die and leave her $50,000.  Inheritance, by law, is separate property.  Now let’s say that Wife puts that money into her joint savings account.  Years pass and Husband and Wife make improvements on their home with money from the savings account.  They make regular deposits into the account and make regular withdrawals for other things too, like trips, gifts and taxes.  Years pass and Wife decides she is bored and is ready to move on.  Can Husband prevent Wife from taking and claiming that $50,000 as her own separate property?  You bet he can.  He needs to have an experienced Boise Divorce Attorney who understands how funds are traced and how comingling re-characterizes the nature of separate property.  This is possible because the funds were treated as community funds.  There was never any regard for keeping the funds separate and they were used freely to benefit the community.

So the above two examples are extremes but comingling occurs all the time.  A very common example I see as a practicing divorce lawyer is when separate property funds are used to purchase a new home.  Does the investment in the new home make the separate property into a community asset?  Generally, no, because the separate funds can be traced and any increase or decrease in value can be divided proportionally. The portion that is paid for with community funds will be characterized as community property.  The portion paid for with separate funds will be characterized as separate property.

If you are getting a divorce and have community property issues we have divorce attorneys who can handle the complexities involved in dividing the marital community.  If you would like to speak with one of our family law attorneys, please give us a call at (208) 472-2383.  You will be glad you did.

Monday, April 9, 2012

Boise Divorce Attorneys - Idaho Family Law Lawyers - Grandparents' Rights

Grandparents' Rights
 As a Boise Divorce Attorney I often receive calls from concerned grandparents who want to know what if they have any rights in regard to their grandchildren.  Sometimes the grandparents have had a very active parent-like role in the grandchildren’s lives.  Sometimes their own son or daughter is not married to the other parent and they are not allowed to see the grandchild at all.  Whatever the situation is, in general these grandparents want to have or to maintain an active role in their grandchildren’s lives.

As a Boise Family Law Lawyer another issue I hear confusion about is grandparent's rights vs. grandparent's receiving custody.  These are two separate issues.  Grandparent's rights refers to visitation with the grandchildren.  Custody refers to the grandparents actually getting custody of their grandchildren.

Idaho Law

What does Idaho Law say about grandparent’s rights?  Not much.  The Idaho Code says that when it is in the grandchild’s best interest visitation may be considered.  In general, if the grandparent has had a very active role in the child’s life they may ask the court to consider granting some visitation to them.  When the grandparent has been denied visitation or has not had an active role, the court is very hesitant to give them visitation.


Military Issues

In my capacity of a divorce lawyer, I often handle military divorce cases.  Grandparent’s rights also come up in this area.  Although the law isn’t applied any differently, there is the potential for the grandparent to have access to visitation that wouldn’t be provided for in a civilian case.  Idaho law allows a member of the military who is on active duty to delegate their right to visitation by power of attorney to whomever they want.  If a grandparent is denied visitation by a custodial parent, they may be able to exercise visitation if their son or daughter who is in the military gives them the right of visitation through a power of attorney.

If you have a custody or visitation issue, or any other family law issue and would like to speak to one of our divorce lawyers, please give us a call, (208) 472-2383 and see what we can do for you.
 

Wednesday, March 14, 2012

Boise Divorce Attorneys - Marriage and Divorce

Marriage
Sometimes the answers to questions are so obvious, we can't believe that they are really the answer.  For example, when does a marriage end?  The most obvious answer is upon divorce, but there is another way.  Death, at least legally, will end a marriage.  A divorce decree will return the parties to the status of unmarried people, but so will death.

Divorce
As a Boise Divorce Attorney another question I am asked occasionally is if a divorce can be denied.  Because divorce is of a legal nature it can be denied, but the denial depends upon the grounds for divorce.  A divorce, for cause, can be denied if the elements of the case are not proven or if they divorce is not filed in a timely fashion.  For example, if you file for divorce on grounds of adultery, you must prove that the other party, in fact, committed adultery.  In addition, you must file for divorce based upon adultery within 2 years of the act or discovering the act.    If you don't your action will be denied.  Another example is divorce on the grounds of felony conviction.  You must file within 1 year of a pardon or the completion of the sentence related to the criminal action.

Can a divorce ever not be denied?  The Idaho Code contains a provision for irreconcilable differences as grounds for divorce.  Irreconcilable differences basically means that you can't get along and that the marriage is ineffective.  This is not a "for cause" action and therefore a divorce on these grounds will not be denied.

Withdrawal of Action
Sometimes a party will file for divorce and then change their mind.  Does this mean that the divorce cannot proceed?  If the plaintiff withdraws their action, the divorce will not go forward.  However, the divorce lawyer for the defendant can actually turn around and refile the case.  They then become the plaintiff.  They must pay a filing fee and have a summons and complaint served upon the other party.

Another form of withdrawal of action I see as a Boise Divorce attorney, is reconciliation.  If it appears that the parties to a divorce may be able to work things out and make the marriage work, the judge can place a stay of 90 days on the proceedings to give the parties a chance at reconciliation. 

If you would like to speak to one of our Boise Divorce Lawyers, please give us a call, (208) 472-2383 and see what we can do for you.

Monday, February 13, 2012

Boise Divorce Attorneys - Custody Issues Prior to Divorce

Custody Issues Prior to Divorce
Obviously it takes some time to get your divorce finalized.  So, what do you do as far as custody with your minor children?  Custody can be handled either formally or informally.

If you want the court to make a formal statement as to custody or you can't agree, your divorce attorney can file a motion for temporary orders.  There is a mini hearing and the judge decides what the visitation schedule will be as well as the custody arrangement.  The respective divorce lawyers will present evidence and statements to the judge and based upon this information the judge will decide.

If you are on working terms with the other parent, you can informally agree on what the arrangement will be.  You, not the judge, makes the decision as to how visitation and custody will be handled.  The problem arises when the parties can't agree and then there is no order to have the court enforce.

Ultimately, the court will decide what the custody arrangement will be.  Hopefully, you are able to work out the intricacies with the other parent through mediation so that it is a custody arrangement that will work for both parties.  The courts and the attorneys like to see custody worked out in mediation because it leads to less need for modification.  You and the other parent know your children and your life style the best so it just makes sense to work out the custody arrangement instead of litigating the issue.

If you have a divorce or custody issue and need to speak to a Boise Divorce Attorney, please call (208) 472-2383 and make an appointment for your free consultation today.

Monday, January 9, 2012

Child Support in Idaho - Boise Family Law Lawyers (208) 472-2383

How is Child Support Determined in Idaho?

As a Boise Divorce Attorney, many people ask me who decides how much their child support will be.  My standard answer is, child support in Idaho is determined by the Idaho Child Support Guidelines. That doesn't tell you much, does it?  

What are the Idaho Child Support Guidelines and what information do they use to set child support?  The purpose of the guidelines is to give guidance in setting a fair child support amount while taking into account the diverse needs and resources available in individual cases.  In other words, it is an attempt to not make a one size fits all child support determination.  In my family law practice I see often see two families, who make the same income, but who have very different resources available to them, as well as greatly varying needs.  This having been said, however, the guidelines also acknowledge that the cost to raise a child is related to the income of the family.  But it also holds that the proportion of family income designated for the support of children remains fairly constant, despite different incomes.

The guidelines apply to the support of all children when custody and support are part of a judicial proceeding, including when there is a divorce or simply a custody action.  Child support is due and owing up until a child reaches 18 years of age, or 19 if they are still in high school.

The guidelines provide a formula for a basic child support determination.  It also provides for off-set considerations.  Some of the adjustments to child support include child care costs, transportation, tax benefit, health insurance premiums and out of pocket health expenses not covered by insurance, and disability or retirement issues, shared physical custody, extended overnights, split physical custody and income over $300,000/year.

The basic formula for child support takes a percentage of both parents income and makes a determination as to how much support it takes to rear a child.  The child support is prorated proportionally to their income.  If one parent does not have an income they are assigned a "potential" income.  In general, this is based upon previous employment or what they could earn based upon their skill level.

Boise Divorce Lawyers deal with the child support guidelines regularly and are very adept at crunching the numbers.  To the general public, however, the guidelines can seem like a convoluted mess.

If you are seeking a divorce or custody and need to speak to a Boise Family Law attorney, please give us a call, (208) 472-2383, and see what we can do for you.